Southgate Amateur Radio News - the amateur radio site for all radio hams
Google
  Web southgatearc.org   
www.southgatearc.org
Page last updated on: Monday, November 15, 2010




   
Dr. R. B. Mannion G3XFD - editor of Practical Wireless

A Future for Digital Radio in the UK?

Practical Wireless editor Rob Mannion recently received an invitation to a seminar where the future of digital radio in the UK is to be discussed.

As you are probably aware, Rob is a well-known critic of DAB - constantly highlighting the impracticalities of the technology - and has founded a national campaign to 'Save Analogue Radio'.

In reponse to the seminar invitation, Rob has sent the following letter to both the Daily Telegraph and Southgate News.


December 7th Seminar in London –
A Future for Digital Radio in the UK?

Dear Sirs: I have just been invited to a seminar in London on Tuesday December 7th, where the future of digital radio in the UK is to be discussed.

The list of those involved is huge, with heavyweight names from the broadcasting industry and those who are seemingly so anxious to enforce the use of the entirely impractical DAB digital radio technology on an unwilling public.

At first, the press announcement seems 'bullish', but on closer reading it seems that the promoters of the technology are trying American wild west wagon train tactics – surrounding themselves with a protective screen consisting of 'heavyweight speakers' in an attempt to bluster their way through to their goal.

However, everyone involved in the pro-DAB radio debate have seemingly totally forgotten – or have not even considered – that the vast majority of radio listening is done with portable radio receivers using inadequate telescopic antennas that can – thanks to modern receiver designs – provide a reliable service in and around the home and in our cars using the traditional analogue f.m. service.

The public have become used to – and expect – to be able to receive a reliable service without having to resort to fixed antennas.

A serially transmitted DAB radio service on the Band II v.h.f. service (it's even worse on the present higher frequency Band III DAB channels) would be entirely unsuitable for use with portable receivers and – unless the Government intend to force millions of listeners to install efficient antennas in their homes, huge numbers of people will find themselves without the essential and reliable radio broadcasting services we've come to expect over the past 50 years or so on the Band II service – or 'f.m.' as it's often called.

I implore the broadcasting industry to remember that without their audience, their activities are wasted.
Please consider the listeners and the impracticality of DAB radio reception without fixed antennas, and the high current demands of digital technology compared with the thoroughly practical 'portable radios' that are economical to power and which are also such an important part of our lives.

Our Islands just cannot afford the costs of the enforcement of this unnecessary digital technology.

Rob Mannion

Rob Mannion G3XFD/EI5IW
Editor Practical Wireless
PW Publishing Ltd.
Arrowsmith Court
Station Approach
Broadstone
Dorset
England BH18 8PW
Tel: (44) (0)845 803 1979



Save Analogue Radio campaign
A National Campaign to maintain essential traditional analogue broadcast radio for everyday listening and for use in times of national emergencies

Click here for more on the campaign

• Click here to support the Save Analogue Radio Campaign

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

 

 
QRZ Callsign Search
Latest news stories..

News Front Page
Get our news headlines for your website
Submit your news story

Get the News Headlines delivered by email
Enter your email address:
Delivered by FeedBurner

Help keep this website going

 

 
Home   Send this page to a friend   News
Index